What are the constitutional consequences if a Menteri Besar resigns? [29/NS]

A Menteri Besar has resigned. Who chooses the next, and does his Executive Council fall with him?

A LETTER AND A COPY

On 16 November a letter went to the palace. It was dated that day and addressed to the Yang di-Pertuan Besar, Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir. In it, Datuk Ismail Lasim resigned as Menteri Besar of Negeri Sembilan.1Bernama (16 November 2026), “Ismail Lasim Resigns As Menteri Besar Of Negeri Sembilan”: https://prn.bernama.com/n9/news/2635340/; Free Malaysia Today (16 November 2026), “Ismail Lasim resigns as Negeri Sembilan MB”: https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2026/11/16/ismail-lasim-resigns-as-negeri-sembilan-mb. Both report the letter through a statement of the Barisan Nasional secretary-general; neither reproduces it.

A copy went to the chairman of Barisan Nasional. That evening the coalition’s secretary-general announced the resignation, and said the chairman would put forward candidates, to be presented to His Highness in accordance with the State Constitution.2Bernama (16 November 2026), above; RTM, “Ismail Lasim letak jawatan MB Negeri Sembilan, calon pengganti akan dikemuka” (16 November 2026): https://berita.rtm.gov.my/nasional/senarai-berita-nasional/senarai-artikel/ismail-lasim-letak-jawatan-mb-negeri-sembilan-calon-pengganti-akan-dikemuka/

So there were two letters. The original went to the one who appoints. The copy went to the one who proposes.

What follows in law? Four things, and this essay takes them in turn.

What this essay leaves alone

The throne, the revocation of the Executive Council’s appointments, and the committal applications are before the courts. This essay takes no view on any of them. It offers no reason for the resignation, because none has been published, and it does not guess at names.

WHAT THE RECORD SHOWS

The sixteenth state election gave Barisan Nasional, with the support of Perikatan Nasional, 25 of the Assembly’s 36 seats. Datuk Ismail took his oath before His Highness on 2 August.3New Straits Times (2 August 2026), Hakim Mahari, “Who is Negri Sembilan’s new Menteri Besar, Datuk Ismail Lasim?”: https://www.nst.com.my/amp/news/nation/2026/08/1502664/who-negri-sembilans-new-menteri-besar-datuk-ismail-lasim; Bernama (2 August 2026): https://bernama.com/en/news.php?id=2589273

On 14 November he confirmed that he had withdrawn a letter of 17 September to the Malay Rulers about His Highness’s throne. The status quo, he said, stood. The Assembly sitting and the 2027 budget still awaited His Highness’s consent.4Bernama (14 November 2026), “Ismail Confirms Withdrawing Letter To Rulers, Maintains Status Quo Of Tunku Muhriz”: https://www.bernama.com/en/general/news.php?id=2634338; The Vibes (14 November 2026): https://www.thevibes.com/articles/news/129557/negeri-mb-confirms-withdrawal-of-letter-to-malay-rulers

Two days later came the resignation.

The record does not say whether it has been accepted, whether Datuk Ismail carries on in the meantime, or why he went. Where the record is silent, so is this essay.

FIRST: THE OFFICE FALLS VACANT

May a Menteri Besar simply resign? He may. Article XXXVIII(5) of the State Constitution ends with a plain sentence: “any member of the Council may at any time resign his office”.5Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(5); the same words close Federal Constitution, Eighth Schedule, Part I, s 2(7). The Menteri Besar presides over that Council, and so is its first member.6Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(2)(a). See 24/NS. Nothing makes his resignation depend on anyone’s acceptance.

An office of this kind is held in trust. It is not a sentence to be served.

Yet the Constitution is silent on the hours that follow. It does not say when a resignation takes effect, and it makes no provision for a caretaker.

Malaysia has met this silence before. On 24 February 2020 the Prime Minister resigned, and the same day the Yang di-Pertuan Agong accepted the resignation and appointed him interim Prime Minister.7Statement of the Chief Secretary to the Government, 24 February 2020, as reported by Malay Mail: https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2020/02/24/agong-accepts-dr-ms-resignation-reappoints-him-as-interim-pm/1840489, and Free Malaysia Today: https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2020/02/24/resignation-accepted-mahathir-appointed-caretaker-pm

The Federal Constitution says nothing of an interim Prime Minister either. Practice filled the gap, because government cannot stop while a choice is made.

SECOND: DOES THE EXECUTIVE COUNCIL FALL WITH HIM?

It is often said that when a Prime Minister resigns, the Cabinet falls with him. Where does that rule come from?

Not, in terms, from the Federal Constitution. Article 43(4) obliges the Prime Minister to tender the Cabinet’s resignation only when he has lost the confidence of the House. Article 43(5) lets the King revoke a Minister’s appointment on the Prime Minister’s advice, and lets any Minister resign.8Federal Constitution, Art 43(4) and (5). Nothing says that the Cabinet ends because the Prime Minister leaves for some other reason.

In 2020 it ended by the second route. The King revoked every Minister’s appointment, on the outgoing Prime Minister’s advice, under Article 43(5).9Malay Mail (24 February 2020), “Agong removes Pakatan ministers after Dr M’s resignation as PM”: https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2020/02/24/agong-removes-pakatan-ministers-after-dr-ms-resignation-as-pm/1840523

The law supplied the means. Convention supplied the expectation.

Westminster offers no clearer text. Erskine May, the great manual of parliamentary procedure, does not deal with the point; it is a matter of convention, not procedure.10Erskine May, Parliamentary Practice (25th ed, 2019), online edition, searched 17 November 2026 (“resignation of the Prime Minister”; “change of Administration”): https://erskinemay.parliament.uk/. Its only references are incidental, for example the interval between Mr Cameron’s announcement in June 2016 and his handing over on 13 July 2016 (Part 8, ch 48). And on the convention, the authorities divide.

One school holds that a government cannot outlive its head. Another, Sir Ivor Jennings among them, holds that a Prime Minister’s personal resignation does not of itself end the government. Professor Anne Twomey, surveying the Commonwealth, preferred the first: the ministry goes with its chief, and carries on only as caretaker.11Anne Twomey, “Changing the Leader: The Constitutional Conventions Concerning the Resignation of Prime Ministers and Premiers” (2011) 39 Federal Law Review 329, Part II.A, citing among others W Ivor Jennings, Cabinet Government (3rd ed) 84–85: https://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/FedLRev/2011/13.pdf

A Malaysian court has taken the same view. In 1994, after Sabah’s Chief Minister resigned, the High Court said it was a well-established convention and usage in Sabah that, on the Chief Minister’s death or resignation, the Cabinet stands dissolved. Any member who is to continue must be reappointed on the new Chief Minister’s advice.12Datuk (Datu) Amir Kahar bin Tun Datu Haji Mustapha v Tun Mohd Said bin Keruak, Yang di-Pertua Negeri Sabah & Ors [1995] 1 MLJ 169 (HC, Abdul Kadir Sulaiman J), at 171 (per curiam) and in the judgment; read on Lexis+, 17 November 2026.

The reason was practical. A new head of government should not have to ask for the removal of colleagues he never chose. That would fetter his choice.

Negeri Sembilan’s text is in the federal mould. Article XXXVIII(4) speaks only of a loss of confidence. Article XXXVIII(5) keeps the other members in office at the Ruler’s pleasure, unless their appointments are revoked on the Menteri Besar’s advice.13Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(4) and (5). The State Constitution does not say, in words, that the Executive Council falls with the Menteri Besar. If it falls, it falls by convention, by revocation, or by fresh appointments that leave no room for the old.

And conventions, the courts insist, are not law. Judges may recognise them; they do not enforce them.14R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5, [141]–[146] and [151], citing Re Resolution to Amend the Constitution [1981] 1 SCR 753: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/uksc/2017/5

A question for the court, not for this essay

That matters, because ten former members of the Executive Council have asked the High Court whether the revocation of their appointments in September was valid. Questions arising from their suit are listed before the Federal Court on 16 December. On 16 November the parties told the High Court that they were exploring a settlement.15Bernama (23 October 2026), “Federal Court Sets Dec 16 Hearing For Negeri Sembilan Excos Dismissal Challenge”: https://www.bernama.com/en/crime_courts/news.php?id=2624687; The Star (16 November 2026), “High Court told of amicable settlement in Negri Sembilan exco suit”: https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2026/11/16/high-court-told-of-amicable-settlement-in-negri-sembilan-exco-suit

The position is difficult, and candour requires saying so.

If the convention operates in Negeri Sembilan, the offices claimed may have ended with the Menteri Besar’s going in any event. The suit would then concern chiefly the weeks between September and November, and the principle.

If it does not, the members’ appointments continue in law until revoked or replaced, and the September question keeps its full force.

Either way, the meaning of Article XXXVIII(5) is for the courts. This essay does not decide it.

THIRD: THE RULER MUST CHOOSE

Barisan Nasional’s statement put things in the right order. The party would propose. His Highness would decide. The Constitution explains why.

Article XXXVI(1) says that the Ruler shall appoint a Menteri Besar, by instrument under his sign manual and the State seal.16Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVI(1). Article XXXVIII(2)(a) says whom: “a member of the Legislative Assembly who in His judgment is likely to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Assembly”.17Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(2)(a); Federal Constitution, Eighth Schedule, Part I, s 2(2)(a), in the same words.

Article XL, which otherwise binds the Ruler to act on advice, places this among the few things he may do “in His discretion”.18Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XL(1), (1A) and (2)(a). It must be so. When there is no Menteri Besar, there is no one to give the advice. Someone must choose the person who will.

The phrase “in His judgment” is crucial. Not the party’s judgment, and not the Prime Minister’s.

“Likely to command.” Not “commands”. The test looks forward. It asks for a forecast of the Assembly, not a vote in it.

“The confidence of the majority of the members of the Assembly.” Not of a party, a coalition, or a supreme council.

That, I suggest, is the principle that ought to govern. The discretion is real, but its object is fixed: whom the Assembly will follow. A party’s list is good evidence of that fact. It is not the fact itself.

The judgment is real

In March 2008 the Raja of Perlis, and days later the Sultan of Terengganu, appointed Menteris Besar other than the names first put forward. In both states the party accepted the choice, and the government that followed was formed by the same party.19Perlis Government Gazette, PSGN 17/2008 (appointment with effect from 14 March 2008): https://govdocs.sinarproject.org/documents/state-governments/perlis/government-of-perlis-gazette/psgn017y2008.pdf; Malaysiakini (14 March 2008): https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/79823; The Star (23 March 2008): https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2008/03/23/sultans-choice-of-mb-stripped-of-umno-membership; The Nut Graph: https://thenutgraph.com/?p=2087. Press reports only; no court considered either appointment.

The Rulers did not override the Assembly. They chose within it.

How is the judgment informed?

The Federal Court has held that a loss of confidence need not be proved by a vote in the Assembly. It may be gathered from other sources, properly established, including what the members themselves have said.20Dato’ Seri Ir Hj Mohammad Nizar bin Jamaluddin v Dato’ Seri Dr Zambry bin Abdul Kadir (Attorney-General, intervener) [2010] 2 MLJ 285 (FC), on Art XVI(6) of the Laws of the Constitution of Perak; read on Lexis+, 17 November 2026. The Court also held that a Menteri Besar who refuses to tender the Executive Council’s resignation under that Article is, with its members, deemed to have vacated office: at [56].

The same must hold, with greater force, for a forecast about a member not yet appointed.

Here the Constitution offers a quiet irony. The respondent in that case, whose appointment the Federal Court upheld, was Datuk Seri Dr Zambry Abd Kadir. On 16 November, as Barisan Nasional’s secretary-general, it was he who announced Datuk Ismail’s resignation.21Datuk Seri Dr Zambry was appointed secretary-general of Barisan Nasional in June 2021: The Malaysian Insight (8 June 2021): https://www.themalaysianinsight.com/s/320417

Few people in the country have studied this machinery more closely, or from nearer the gears.

THE NEGERI SEMBILAN DIFFERENCE

So far, this could be any of the nine Malay States. Negeri Sembilan adds something of its own.

Article XXVIII(2) says who “the Ruler” is for the discretions in Article XL(2): “His Highness and at least three of the four Undangs”, or two if only three hold office.22Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXVIII(2), read in the reprints incorporating amendments to 9 October 2003 and to 1 January 2008; to be confirmed against the current reprint before publication. A proviso lets His Highness act alone in two matters. The appointment of a Menteri Besar is not one of them.

The Federal Constitution recognises the design. For Negeri Sembilan, “Ruler” means the Yang di-Pertuan Besar “acting on behalf of himself and the Ruling Chiefs in accordance with the Constitution of that State”.23Federal Constitution, Art 160(2), definition of “Ruler”.

This is the State’s history, written into its law. The Undangs elect the Yang di-Pertuan Besar.24Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXIV(1), definition of “His Highness”, referring to Art VII. A State whose Ruler is chosen by its chiefs shares with them the gravest of his discretions.

The text does not say how that concurrence is given. It prescribes no form and no record. Who holds each Undangship is among the matters before the courts, and this essay draws no inference from it.

But notice what is shared. Not a preference: the same single question, who is likely to command the Assembly, put to more than one mind. The design adds counsel to the judgment. It does not change its object.

FOURTH: THE ASSEMBLY WAITS, AND THEN DECIDES

The Executive Council is “collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly”.25Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(3). The appointment is a forecast. The Assembly is where it is tested.

The Assembly meets when the Ruler summons it, and the summons is given on advice.26Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Arts LVI(1) and XL(1). The 2027 budget waits for that sitting, and no money may leave the Consolidated Fund without a law to allow it.27Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXXIV(1). See 24/NS. A new Menteri Besar is therefore the first link in the chain of advice on which the summons, and the budget, depend.

THE ANSWER

So, what are the constitutional consequences if a Menteri Besar resigns?

The office falls vacant, though the Constitution does not say who minds it in the meantime.

The Executive Council may fall with him. If it does, the rule is convention, not text, and its force in Negeri Sembilan is for the courts.

The Ruler must choose, and in Negeri Sembilan the Ruler for this purpose is His Highness with at least three of the four Undangs. The judgment is genuine, and it is about one thing: who is likely to command the Assembly.

The Assembly decides in the end.

Burke wrote that a state without the means of some change is without the means of its conservation.28Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790). The State Constitution has the means. It lacks only a sentence or two. One would keep the outgoing Menteri Besar in office until his successor is sworn. Another would say whether his Executive Council goes with him. A written constitution should not leave its most anxious hours to convention.

For the young practitioner, one evening will do. Read Articles XXVIII, XXXVI and XXXVIII side by side, then the judgments in the Perak and Sabah cases. By next week you will be able to answer the client who asks “Who decides?”, in three sentences, and be right in all three.

∞§∞

 

This is for general information only, not legal or technical advice. Obtain independent legal advice where needed.

Thanks to KN Geetha, TP Vaani, JN Lheela and Lydia Jaynthi of GK Legal, and Michael Fourset of Unsplash for the image.

Claude assisted with drafting; Perplexity Pro fact-checked. The views and any errors are the author’s.

© GK Ganesan Kasinathan. All rights reserved. All site content is protected by copyright. No reproduction or use without prior written permission: gk@gkganesan.com.

You May Also Like

Apakah akibat perlembagaan jika Menteri Besar meletak jawatan? [BM-29/NS]

Adakah notis yang lewat menjadikan sidang Dewan Negeri Sembilan tidak sah? [BM-28/NS]

Does a late notice make the Negeri Sembilan sitting invalid? [28/NS]

Trump’s party lost Congress. Why is he still President?