How must a Menteri Besar prove his majority: by signatures, or by a vote in the Assembly? [31/NS]
Seven signatures on Friday. A swearing-in expected on Sunday. But how does anyone prove a majority, and where?
ONE MORNING, TWO STATEMENTS
On the morning of 20 November, Ismail Lasim went to Istana Hinggap for an audience. The Undang were present.1Malay Mail, “Not so fast: Negeri Sembilan palace says Ismail Lasim must show majority support, not just deny resigning as MB” (20 November 2026); Bernama (20 November 2026).
He then told the press that he had neither sent, nor agreed to send, the resignation letter dated 16 November. He had been told, he said, to carry on.2Bernama, “Ismail Lasim To Remain As Negeri Sembilan MB On Tuanku Muhriz’s Decree” (20 November 2026); Malaysiakini (20 November 2026).
By the evening the palace had spoken too.
It had not, it said, asked him to remain. He must show that he still has the support of a majority of the Assembly, and submit a list of proposed Exco members. The dates of the next sitting, and of the 2027 budget, would be fixed once those matters were settled.3Bernama (BM), “Istana Negeri Sembilan: Ismail Lasim Mesti Buktikan Sokongan Majoriti Untuk Kekal Sebagai MB” (20 November 2026, 6.38 pm); Malay Mail; Free Malaysia Today; New Straits Times (20 November 2026).
A SWEARING-IN, EXPECTED ON SUNDAY
On the afternoon of 20 November, seven assemblymen signed letters of undertaking before the Menteri Besar, in his office.4Berita Harian, “7 EXCO baharu Negeri Sembilan tandatangani aku janji, dijangka angkat sumpah Ahad ini” (20 November 2026), citing an unnamed source. As this essay is written, on 21 November, they are expected to be sworn in as Exco members on Sunday, at Istana Besar Seri Menanti. The source is unnamed; no date has been announced officially.5Ibid; Utusan Malaysia / UtusanMelayuPlus, “Tujuh Exco baharu Negeri Sembilan dijangka angkat sumpah Ahad ini” (20 November 2026), reporting Sinar Harian.
A letter of undertaking is a promise to serve. It is not a vote of confidence. Seven members and a Menteri Besar make eight of thirty-six.
So the palace’s second condition, the Exco list, may soon be met. Whether, and how, the first has been met has not been announced.
That is the education in this moment. How can thirty-six members tell anyone, outside the chamber, whom they trust? Malaysian history knows four ways: a letter, a statutory declaration, an audience, and a vote.
So a test has been set. Where is it to be sat? And in what order?
What this essay leaves alone
It takes no view on the letter, on who should lead the state, or on the throne. It asks only what the law says about proving a majority, and what the law’s own history says about doing it well.
A PLACE THAT CREPT INTO THE TRANSLATION
In Bahasa Malaysia, Ismail must prove that he still has “sokongan majoriti ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri”.6Bernama (BM), 20 November 2026, as above.
That is the support of a majority of the members of the Assembly. It names whose support counts. It does not say where it must be shown.
Some English reports added a place: majority support “in the State Legislative Assembly”.7Bernama (English), “Negeri Sembilan Palace: Ismail Lasim Must Prove Majority Support To Remain MB”; Malay Mail (both 20 November 2026).
Three small words, and the meaning tilts.
“In the Assembly” sounds like a vote.
“Of the members” can be met at a desk, with a pen.
WHAT THE CONSTITUTION SAYS, AND WHAT IT LEAVES OUT
Article XXXVIII of the Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959 does the work.
At the beginning, the Ruler appoints as Menteri Besar a member, “who in His judgment is likely to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the Assembly”.8Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959 (2008 Reprint), Art XXXVIII(2)(a).
“Likely” is a forecast, not a count.
At the end, if he, “ceases to command the confidence of the majority”, then, unless the Assembly is dissolved at his request, “he shall tender the resignation of the Executive Council”.9Ibid, Art XXXVIII(4).
Neither clause says how confidence is measured.
Where the text is silent, the courts have spoken, and not with one voice.
THREE ANSWERS, AND ONE OF THEM BINDS
Kuching, 1966
In June 1966, a letter reached the Governor of Sarawak. It listed twenty-five members of the Council Negri. Twenty-one had signed; one of those “signatures” was only a stamp (often called in Malaysia, a “chop”).
They no longer supported their Chief Minister, Stephen Kalong Ningkan, who was not shown the letter until the litigation began.10Stephen Kalong Ningkan v Tun Abang Haji Openg & Tawi Sli [1966] 2 MLJ 187 (HC, Kuching, Harley Ag CJ), judgment text, letter of 16 June 1966 and the list attached.
The Governor dismissed him.
Ningkan sued, and won. Under the Sarawak Constitution, the High Court held, a lack of confidence “may be demonstrated only by a vote in the Council Negri”.11Ibid, holding (1).
London, 1963
Three years earlier, the Privy Council had given the opposite answer for Western Nigeria.
A letter from a majority of the House was enough to remove the Premier, Chief Akintola, though the House had never voted.12Adegbenro v Akintola [1963] AC 614; [1963] UKPC 15 (27 May 1963), BAILII printed judgment pp 1 and 7.
Viscount Radcliffe gave the advice.
Letters, speeches and party meetings, he said, are all “capable of contributing evidence”.
Yet everything comes back in the end to what members do, “on the floor of the House”.13Ibid, p 5. And he gave a warning worth framing: such expressions “may well prove to be delusive”.14Ibid, p 6.
Radcliffe gave the BBC’s Reith Lectures in 1951, under the title Power and the State.
His theme was how free people guard against the abuse of power.15BBC Programme Index, “The Reith Lectures: Cyril Radcliffe – Power and the State” (1951); review in The Spectator (4 April 1952), p 37.
His judgments share the gift of those lectures: a hard question laid out so plainly that the answer seems to arrive on its own.
Then came a twist.
On the very day of the judgment, the Western Region amended its constitution: a Premier could now be removed only after, “a resolution in the House of Assembly”, back-dated to 1960.16Constitution of Western Nigeria (Amendment) Law 1963, enacted 27 May 1963, as recited by the Federal Supreme Court of Nigeria (Bairamian FJ) in its costs ruling in Adegbenro v Akintola (1963), reported at lawcarenigeria.com.
One question. Two answers. One day.
Putrajaya, 2010
Malaysia took Radcliffe’s road, and said so.
Nothing in the Constitution says, the Federal Court held in the Nizar case, that loss of confidence “may only be established through a vote” in the Assembly.
Evidence may be gathered from other sources “provided, as stated in Akintola, they are properly established”.17Dato’ Seri Ir Hj Mohammad Nizar bin Jamaluddin v Dato’ Seri Dr Zambry bin Abdul Kadir [2010] 2 MLJ 285 (FC) at [48]; and at [56]: confidence “may be determined by means other than a vote of no confidence”. The Court quoted Radcliffe at length, and noted that Amir Kahar [1995] 1 MLJ 169 (HC) had adopted him: at [41]–[43]. The Perak story is told in 9/NS and 16/NS.
That answer binds every Malaysian court today.
WHY OTHERS INSIST ON THE FLOOR
Bangalore, 1989
India learned the other lesson, and learned it the hard way.
In April 1989 a legislator handed the Governor of Karnataka nineteen letters withdrawing support from the Chief Minister, S R Bommai. The next day, seven of the nineteen wrote again. Their signatures, they said, had been obtained “by misrepresentation”.18S R Bommai v Union of India (1994) 3 SCC 1 at [117].
Bommai offered to prove his majority on the floor of the House, within the week. The offer was not taken up, and President’s Rule followed.19Ibid at [117]; and at [155] (K Ramaswamy J).
The Supreme Court of India called the floor “the constitutionally ordained forum”. The proper course had been “to await the test on the floor of the House”.20Ibid at [118]–[119]. Repeated in Shivraj Singh Chouhan (below) at [40]: “the only way of testing it is on the floor of the House”.
The Court has kept a balance since. A Governor may call a floor test even mid-session, but a court may ask whether he did so “on the basis of objective material and reasons which were relevant and germane”.21Shivraj Singh Chouhan v Speaker, Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly 2020 SCC OnLine SC 363; 2020 INSC 335 (13 April 2020, Chandrachud and Hemant Gupta JJ) at [43]; see also [42] and [47]. Without such material, “discontent on the part of some MLAs is not sufficient”. Nor may a floor test be used “to resolve internal party disputes”.22Subhash Desai v Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra (Constitution Bench, 11 May 2023, Chandrachud CJI) at [186] and [188]; conclusion at [206(h)]
Why India does not decide Negeri Sembilan
Three differences matter.
India’s Governors are appointed by the Union government. Bommai’s case grew out of a federal power to remove a state’s government, and fears of its misuse. Nothing in it concerns a hereditary Ruler.
India’s Supreme Court binds India. Here, Nizar binds.
And Bommai’s House could have sat within a week. Whether Negeri Sembilan’s can is the question below.
WHEN SIGNATURES GO WRONG AT HOME
Malaysia has its own record of paper majorities that did not hold.
In February 2020 the Yang di-Pertuan Agong took the unprecedented course of interviewing all 222 members of the Dewan Rakyat, one by one.23Malay Mail, “In unprecedented move, Agong to interview each MP to determine who commands majority” (25 February 2020). The palace then announced that no member had been identified as commanding a majority.24Malay Mail / Yahoo News, “Pakatan claims Anwar commands majority support to be PM” (Ida Lim, 2020), quoting the Istana Negara statement.
Professor Shad Saleem Faruqi likened members avowing loyalty to rival leaders to teng-teng, the children’s hopscotch.25Shad Saleem Faruqi, “Appointment of a Prime Minister” (Malaysian Bar and ISIS Malaysia, March 2020).
In Sabah that July, a rival claimed thirty-three statutory declarations. The state palace said it never received them.26The Star, “Sabah governor never received 33 SDs or requests to meet Musa, says private secretary” (6 August 2020); Malay Mail (30 July 2020).
Radcliffe had a word for it. Delusive.
IS THE FEDERAL COURT RIGHT?
Yes, and for a reason the judgments do not stress.
An Assembly meets only ‘when summoned’, and it is ‘summoned on advice’.27Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Arts LVI(1) and XL(1). See 27/NS and 29/NS.
If the floor were the only forum, a head of government who had lost his majority could postpone the test by advising no sitting.
The one judge entitled to decide would be locked out of its own courtroom.
But the rule leaves a gap.
The phrase, “Properly established” is nowhere defined. The record above shows why that gap matters.
WHAT MAKES PROOF OUTSIDE THE CHAMBER PROPER
The law’s own history suggests four tests.
In writing, and on oath
A bare list is the weakest proof. Ningkan’s list carried a chop; Karnataka’s nineteen letters were a list. A statutory declaration is a list with a penalty: a false one is punishable as false evidence under the Penal Code.28Statutory Declarations Act 1960, s 3, which deems such declarations to be declarations for the purposes of the Penal Code, ss 199–200 (s 199: “False statement made in any declaration which is by law receivable as evidence”).
Individual and recent
Each member signs for himself, and the date is close to the decision. Support is a perishable good.
Exclusive
A name that appears on two lists counts for neither until its owner says, in person, which he meant. The fault the Supreme Court of India found in Karnataka was that no one asked.29S R Bommai at [117]–[118]: the Governor had the signatures checked through the secretariat but did not interview the legislators.
Confirmed on the floor
In 2021 the federal sequence ran from declaration, to audience, to appointment. Istana Negara added that the new Prime Minister must, as soon as possible, move a motion of confidence in the Dewan Rakyat.30Istana Negara statement of 18 August 2021, reported by The Edge and Malay Mail (18 August 2021); Malay Mail (20 August 2021).
CAN THE FLOOR BE REACHED IN TIME?
Not quickly. Every sitting begins with a summons in the Ruler’s name, given on advice. The August sitting does not carry the next one forward.
In practice, consent comes first, then the Speaker’s notice.31Penyata Dewan Undangan Negeri Sembilan, 12 October 2023, pp 216–217. See 28/NS and 29/NS. A Menteri Besar tied that notice in 2021 to twenty-eight days under the Standing Orders, shorter if important and necessary, subject to consent.32Bernama via Astro Awani (18 June 2021), citing Peraturan IV Perintah 5. The Standing Orders’ own text has not been seen by this desk.
No Menteri Besar can call the Assembly on his own.
So the order sets itself: proof outside the chamber first, the floor after.
THE REHEARSAL AND THE OPENING NIGHT
Signatures are the rehearsal. They show whether the cast know their lines, and help decide who takes the stage.
The floor is the opening night: doors open, every vote counted and recorded, each member answerable to his voters.
The opening night has a date already. No money leaves the Consolidated Fund without a Supply Enactment.33Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXXIV(1). See 24/NS and 27/NS. Even spending for part of the year needs the Legislature.34Ibid, Art LXXIV(4).
The budget, then, is the floor test, in all but name. If it falls, the House has spoken. That risk belongs to any Menteri Besar who goes before the House, as it should.
If the majority is not shown
Article XXXVIII(4) applies to any Menteri Besar: he tenders the Executive Council’s resignation, unless the Assembly is dissolved at his request.35Ibid, Art XXXVIII(4). On dissolution, see 16/NS. Consent to a dissolution, and the choice of a successor, are among the few matters the Ruler decides in his own discretion, with at least three of the Undang.36Ibid, Arts XL(2)(a)–(b) and XXVIII(2). See 29/NS. This essay goes no further than the text.
THE ANSWER
Where must a Menteri Besar prove his majority?
In law, outside the chamber is enough to begin with, if the proof is properly established. That is Nizar, and it binds.
But the better view is that the floor is the test to be preferred. It is public, it is counted, and it cannot be signed twice. Radcliffe said everything comes back to it; Karnataka shows what happens when it is skipped.
In what order?
Proof first, on oath, individual, exclusive and recent.
Then the floor, at the first sitting the calendar allows.
In Negeri Sembilan that sitting carries the budget.
Of the great question he decided in 1963, Radcliffe wrote that it lay “within a very small compass”.37Adegbenro v Akintola [1963] UKPC 15, BAILII printed judgment p 4.
∞§∞
This is for general information only, not legal or technical advice. Obtain independent legal advice where needed.
Thanks to KN Geetha, TP Vaani, JN Lheela and Lydia Jaynthi of GK Legal, and Art Lasovsky of Unsplash for the image.
Claude assisted with drafting; Perplexity Pro fact-checked. The views and any errors are the author’s.
© GK Ganesan Kasinathan. All rights reserved. All site content is protected by copyright. No reproduction or use without prior written permission: gk@gkganesan.com.