A SALARY AND A CLAUSE

At the end of January, a clerk at a district land office in Jempol will check her bank balance.

She has a car loan, and a daughter in Form Four.

Whether her salary is there depends on a clause written in 1959 that almost nobody has read.

The clause is short. No money may leave the state’s Consolidated Fund unless the law charges it there, or a Supply Enactment allows it.¹Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959 (2008 Reprint), Art LXXIV(1).

A Supply Enactment is simply the state’s budget, made law. It has to be passed afresh every year.

Her salary is not charged. It must be voted.

So if no budget passes by 31 December, the state cannot lawfully pay most of its own staff from 1 January.

In an ordinary year, that is a routine deadline. This year, it is not.

On the government’s own account, the seats around the Executive Council table wait to be filled, and will be filled in due course.²The Star (8 October 2026); Bernama (8 October 2026).

So the clerk’s question is a real one. Can a state pass its budget while its Executive Council stands nearly empty?

What this essay leaves alone

Two matters are before the courts, and they stay there.

One is whether the ten Exco members removed on 20 September still hold office. The other is the dispute over the throne.³The former Exco members filed suit on 5 October 2026: The Star (8 October 2026). The related committal applications: Malay Mail (19 October 2026).

This essay takes no view on either. It asks only what the Constitution requires before a budget is passed and a law is made.

A COUNCIL BUILT FOR FIVE

On size, the Constitution is plain. “The Ruler shall appoint an Executive Council”: the Menteri Besar, and “not more than ten nor less than four other members”.⁴Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(1) and (2).

Five at the least. Eleven at the most.

Filling it is a matter of paper. Members are appointed “on the advice of the Menteri Besar”, which in practice means a written list.⁵Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(2)(b).

On 20 September, the palace asked for that list.⁶Istana Besar Seri Menanti statement (20 September 2026), as reported by Malay Mail (21 September 2026).

The oath is flexible too. A new member swears it before His Highness, “or some person authorized by His Highness in that behalf”.⁷Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXIX.

His Highness, for his part, may call for any information about the government that the Council holds.⁸Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XL(1). Walter Bagehot called it “the right to be consulted”, the first of a constitutional monarch’s three rights. Negeri Sembilan wrote it into law.⁹Walter Bagehot, The English Constitution (1867), ch III.

On 8 October, the Menteri Besar said the empty seats need not be filled before the budget. Department heads prepare the figures; the Exco usually endorses them later.¹⁰The Star (8 October 2026).

His point is practical. But the drafters never pictured a Council of one, and one clause gives them away.

No business may be done, it says, if a member present objects that fewer than four members sit besides the chair.¹¹Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XLII.

It is a fine safeguard. It does, however, need someone present to object.

WHAT BELFAST DECIDED

Another part of the Commonwealth has lived this question in earnest.

From early 2017, Northern Ireland had no ministers for almost three years. Its departments ran on under senior civil servants.

In September 2017, one department approved a £240 million waste incinerator at Hightown Quarry, near Mallusk.¹²ITV News (UTV) (14 May 2018).

Colin Buick, who chaired a residents’ group called NoArc21, went to court.

On 6 July 2018, the Court of Appeal in Belfast held the approval unlawful. The decision, said Morgan LCJ and Stephens LJ, “was crosscutting, significant and controversial”. It belonged to elected ministers, not to an official acting alone.¹³Re Buick’s Application for Judicial Review [2018] NICA 26 at [56] and [58] (Morgan LCJ and Stephens LJ), affirming Keegan J. Official text: judiciaryni.uk.

Treacy LJ was blunter. The department’s position was “profoundly undemocratic”.¹⁴Re Buick’s Application for Judicial Review [2018] NICA 26 at [64] (Treacy LJ).

Westminster then had to pass a special Act so that Belfast’s civil servants could keep taking decisions at all.¹⁵Northern Ireland (Executive Formation and Exercise of Functions) Act 2018 (c 28).

Negeri Sembilan is not Northern Ireland. It has an elected Menteri Besar, answerable to an elected Assembly.

But the Belfast rule travels well. The bigger and more contested a decision, the more firmly it belongs to people who must answer for it in public.

No decision is bigger than a state’s budget. So where does the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan send it?

THROUGH A NARROW DOOR

Every budget begins as a statement of the coming year’s money. The Ruler, on his government’s advice, causes it to be laid before the Assembly before the year begins.¹⁶Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Arts LXXI(1) and XL(1).

The spending is then put into a Supply Bill.¹⁷Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXXII.

And there the bill meets a narrow door. A bill that spends public money may be moved only “by a member of the Executive Council”.¹⁸Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXIV(2).

The Menteri Besar holds that key. He is appointed “to preside over the Executive Council”, which makes him its first member.¹⁹Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art XXXVIII(2)(a).

So the door is narrow, but it opens. On the text, he may move the Supply Bill himself.

Beyond the door sits the Assembly. It decides by a simple majority of those voting.²⁰Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LX(3).

That is the Belfast lesson, already built in. Whatever the state of the Exco, the year’s biggest decision is taken in public, by people who must face the voters.

AND THE LAWS?

A bill becomes law when the Assembly passes it and the Ruler assents, by affixing the State Seal and signing it.²¹Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXIV(1).

Few readers know what follows. Assent is to be given within thirty days of a bill being presented. If it is not, the bill “shall become law” as if it had been.²²Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXIV(2A) and (2B). Article LXIV was amended by Enactment No 10 of 1995, in force 19 January 1996, according to the amendment table of the 2008 Reprint.

That clock runs for every bill and every reign. It judges no one. It simply means a law cannot stall forever at its last step.

THE DATE THAT DOES NOT MOVE

Money is less forgiving.

A short list of payments runs on without any vote: the Civil List, the state’s debts, and court judgments against it.²³Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXX(1).

The clerk in Jempol is not on that list.

There is a stopgap. The Legislature may vote money for part of a year before the full budget passes.²⁴Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Art LXXIV(4). But even the stopgap needs the Assembly to sit and vote.

The government proposes to open the Assembly on 26 November and table the 2027 budget the next day.²⁵The Star (8 October 2026); Bernama (8 October 2026). The sitting first fixed for 16 October was postponed: The Vibes (16 October 2026).

The Assembly is summoned by the Ruler, on his government’s advice.²⁶Laws of the Constitution of Negeri Sembilan 1959, Arts LVI(1) and XL(1).

Five weeks, then, from tabling to the year’s end. Enough, if the ground is firm.

THE ANSWER

Does Negeri Sembilan need its Exco to pass a budget?

To table one, no. The Menteri Besar may move the Supply Bill himself, and the Assembly decides.

To fill the Council, nothing is needed but paper: a list of names, and an oath before His Highness or his nominee.

But the Constitution plainly expects a Council of at least five. A budget moved by a Council of one stands on ground the drafters never surveyed, and unsurveyed ground invites a lawsuit.

A full Council invites none. That is the cure the text itself prescribes, and the only one that needs no lawyer.

The clerk in Jempol does not care who wins.

At the end of January, she will look at one number on a small screen. Whether it is there depends on paper, on numbers, and on a date that is not open to persuasion.

∞§∞

This is for general information only, not legal or technical advice. Obtain independent legal advice where needed.

Thanks to KN Geetha, TP Vaani, JN Lheela and Lydia Jaynthi of GK Legal, and Aron Visuals of Unsplash for the image.

Claude assisted with drafting; Perplexity Pro fact-checked. The views and any errors are the author’s.

© GK Ganesan Kasinathan. All rights reserved. All site content is protected by copyright. No reproduction or use without prior written permission: gk@gkganesan.com.