Why should the Pardons Board decide mercy in secret, and who has the power to say so? [1/PB]

No law makes a Pardons Board meeting secret. A rubber stamp does. And no court, says the Act, may ask why.

Two words sat on the same page.

At the top, Rahsia. Secret. At the bottom, Terbuka. Open.

The pages were said to be extracts from the minutes of the 64th meeting of the Pardons Board for the Federal Territories, held at Istana Negara on 18 September. They appeared on a former MP’s Facebook page on 18 November.1“Alleged declassified minutes on Najib’s house arrest shared on social media”, The Star, 18 November 2026 (pages 3, 5, 6, 7 and 8; “Rahsia” at the top left; “Terbuka” and “Rahsia” at the bottom right). Malay Mail reported the same day that it had not verified the papers.

A secret, it seems, can also be open. Only a rubber stamp could manage both at once.

This essay asks the question underneath the stamp. Why should a meeting about mercy be secret at all?

WHO MADE THE MINUTES SECRET?

Not the Constitution

Article 42 of the Federal Constitution creates the Board. It says who sits on it, who presides, and what the Board must read before it advises.2Federal Constitution, art 42(5)–(9) and (11), read at source (Lexis+ Malaysia, Unannotated Statutes), 19 November 2026.

It does not say one word about confidentiality.

Not Parliament, by name

The Official Secrets Act 1972 lists in its Schedule the papers that are secret by force of law. Cabinet papers. State Executive Council papers. Papers on national security, defence and foreign relations.3Official Secrets Act 1972, s 2 and Schedule, as set out in Endau Gemilang Sdn Bhd v Kementerian Kewangan [2025] MLJU 1000.

The minutes of a Pardons Board are not on that list.

A stamp, and nothing more

They became secret another way. Section 2 lets a Minister, or an officer he appoints under section 2B, classify any official document as secret.4Official Secrets Act 1972, ss 2 (“official secret”) and 2B, read at source, 19 November 2026.

There is no test of national security. There is no test at all. The stamp needs no reason.

Then section 16A seals the door. An official’s certificate that a paper is secret is “conclusive evidence” of it, and “shall not be questioned in any court on any ground whatsoever”.5Official Secrets Act 1972, s 16A, inserted by the Official Secrets (Amendment) Act 1986 (A660); read at source, 19 November 2026.

So the secrecy of mercy in Malaysia rests on an official’s stamp.

WAS THE STAMP LAWFULLY LIFTED?

What we know

On 12 November, the Home Minister told Parliament he would ask the Cabinet to declassify the minutes.6“Saifuddin to propose declassification of Pardons Board minutes on Najib’s house arrest”, Malaysiakini, 12 November 2026; “Cabinet to hear call for disclosure”, The Star, 13 November 2026.

The next day, the government’s spokesman said the matter was not raised directly in Cabinet. The Attorney General’s advice had been sought, he said, and the process would follow the law.7“Process ongoing to declassify Najib pardon minutes, says Fahmi”, The Star, 13 November 2026.

Five days later, the pages were online. One portal reported that they had been declassified for the Malaysian Bar’s case in court.8“Declassified: Agong wanted house arrest for Najib despite objections”, Malaysiakini, 18 November 2026.

On 19 November the Prime Minister said that such papers are usually declassified once they are challenged in court.9“Declassification of Pardons Board documents not unusual – PM Anwar”, theSun, 19 November 2026.

What we do not know

Section 2C says who may lift the stamp: a Minister, or a public officer charged with responsibility for the department concerned.10Official Secrets Act 1972, s 2C, read at source, 19 November 2026.

The Law Minister, speaking as her party’s information chief, asked the obvious questions. Who lifted it? When? On what authority?11“Azalina demands explanation over leaked Najib Pardons Board minutes”, Malay Mail, 18 November 2026.

At the time of writing, no official statement had answered them.

So the honest answer is this: we do not yet know whether the stamp was lifted lawfully. Nor, it must be said, do we know why it was put there in the first place.

WHY SHOULD MERCY BE DECIDED IN SECRET?

The best case for the closed door

The case for privacy is real, and deserves its best advocate.

A petition for mercy is not an appeal. In 1979 Suffian LP put it in a sentence: when the King considers a pardon, he “does not sit as a court”, and may weigh what courts cannot.12Public Prosecutor v Soon Seng Sia Heng [1979] 2 MLJ 170 at 171 (FC), as quoted in Juraimi bin Husin v Pardons Board, State of Pahang [2002] 4 MLJ 529 (FC) at 534–535.

Tun Suffian, Lord President from 1974 to 1982, wrote as he spoke: plainly, and without a wasted word. His An Introduction to the Constitution of Malaysia is still in print; a student who wants to know how our Constitution was first read should find it this week.13S Jayakumar reviewed the second edition at (1976) 18 Mal LR 365. A current edition is published by Pacifica Publications.

What a Pardons Board weighs is often intimate. A prisoner’s illness. His family. The grief of those he harmed. Such things are not for the front page.

There is the dignity of the Ruler too. His Majesty presides over the Board and stands above party.14Federal Constitution, art 42(8) and (11). He should never be made a contestant in a quarrel between politicians.

Why that case runs out

Every one of those reasons protects a person. None protects a decision.

The prisoner’s medical file can be kept back. The victim’s letter can be kept back. Neither needs a stamp on the whole meeting.

And none of those reasons explains why the public may not know what the Attorney General and a Minister advised, when they advise in the people’s name.

WHAT THE COMMON LAW LEARNT, THE HARD WAY

Three cases, one lesson

England learnt this lesson first, and reluctantly.

In 1975 the government tried to stop the publication of a dead Cabinet minister’s diaries. Lord Widgery refused. Ten years had passed. Nobody could show that publication would harm anyone.15Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752, as discussed by Lord Keith of Kinkel in Attorney-General v Guardian Newspapers Ltd (No 2) [1988] 3 All ER 545 (HL) at 640–641; [1990] 1 AC 109.

In 1980, in Australia, Mason J went further. A government, he said, is not a private person. Exposing its conduct to public discussion and criticism is no harm to it at all.16Commonwealth of Australia v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1980) 32 ALR 485 at 492–493 (HCA), quoted in full by Lord Keith in [1988] 3 All ER 545 at 641–642.

Then came Spycatcher. A retired intelligence officer’s memoir was being read across the world while the British government tried to stop its own newspapers from reporting it. In 1988 the House of Lords agreed with Mason J. A government cannot ask a court to keep its secrets unless it shows that publication would harm the public interest.17[1988] 3 All ER 545 at 642 (Lord Keith of Kinkel).

Lord Goff added the obvious. Once information has entered the public domain, the duty of confidence, as a rule, has nothing left to protect.18Ibid at 659 (Lord Goff of Chieveley).

Notice what moved. The burden. The government must show harm. The citizen need not show a right.

Our law stands where England stood before 1975

Malaysia’s section 16A turns that lesson on its head. The official decides, and the court may not ask why.

But our own Federal Court has set a limit on clauses like that. In Indira Gandhi it held that the courts’ power to review the legality of official action cannot be shut out, “even by an express ouster clause”.19Indira Gandhi a/p Mutho v Pengarah Jabatan Agama Islam Perak [2018] 1 MLJ 545 (FC) at [124]–[132], 593–595; see also [129], citing Menteri Sumber Manusia v Association of Bank Officers, Peninsular Malaysia [1999] 2 MLJ 337 (FC).

It is submitted that section 16A, so far as it bars every court on every ground, is vulnerable on that reasoning. The stamp may stand. The court door may not be bolted behind it.

THIS IS NOT NATIONAL SECURITY

Whose money, whose secret?

Some have said that releasing the minutes threatens national security.20“Unauthorised release of classified documents threatens national security, says Zambry”, New Straits Times, 19 November 2026 (headline and summary only; the full article could not be retrieved).

With respect, the security of the nation was not on the table that morning. Mercy was.

When the petitioner holds high public office and stands convicted of an offence against public money, the case for secrecy is at its weakest.

That money might have built a school, a ward, a road. The public paid for it. The public is entitled to watch how the law treats those who took it.

Secrecy in such a case protects no state secret. It protects only the comfort of the powerful. That is not national security. It is national insecurity.

A door the Constitution already provides

The Constitution does demand secrecy in one place, and it is worth reading carefully.

Every Minister swears an oath of secrecy. He promises not to reveal what comes to him as Minister, except as his duties require “or as may be specially permitted by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong”.21Federal Constitution, art 43(6) and Sixth Schedule (Oath of Secrecy), read at source, 19 November 2026.

So the key to openness already lies, by the Constitution’s own words, in the royal hand.

THE ANSWER

Secrecy is the exception, and it must earn its keep

So should a Pardons Board meet in secret?

No law says it must. A stamp says it may. And a stamp, unlike the law, need give no reasons.

It is submitted that four rules would serve mercy and the public alike.

First, every decision and its conditions should be published at once.

Second, where the petitioner held public office and was convicted of an offence against public money, the advice of the Attorney General and the Minister should be published too, with private medical and family matters kept back.

Third, any classification should be open to a court’s review, as the Federal Court’s reasoning already suggests it must be.

Fourth, Parliament should say so in plain words, rather than leave mercy to the rubber stamp.

Mercy is the Ruler’s to give. But the people are entitled to see how it was asked for, and by whom it was opposed.

The light should fall on the petition, not only on the leak.

 

∞§∞

 

 

This is for general information only, not legal or technical advice. Obtain independent legal advice where needed.

Thanks to KN Geetha, TP Vaani, JN Lheela and Lydia Jaynthi of GK Legal, and Zoshua Colah of Unsplash for the image.

Claude assisted with drafting; Perplexity Pro fact-checked. The views and any errors are the author’s.

© GK Ganesan Kasinathan. All rights reserved. All site content is protected by copyright. No reproduction or use without prior written permission: gk@gkganesan.com.

 

You May Also Like

When injustice strikes, why do Malaysians leave the Bar Council to hold up the sky alone?

Mengapa Mesyuarat Lembaga Pengampunan Mesti Dirahsiakan, dan Siapa yang Berkuasa Menentukannya? [BM-1/PB]

If you miss a premium on your life insurance policy, must the insurer remind you before the policy ends?

Can a Deputy Speaker leave the Chair empty, debate as an MP, and still preside over the Dewan Rakyat?